Jordan Koschei: Best atmosphere in New Paltz. On summer nights it's great to sit outside near the fire pits under the lights. Or, go upstairs and check out their board game collection.
Jordan Koschei: Some of the best pizza I've ever had, and it was in Phoenix of all places (rather than my home state of New York). Also, Giada de Laurentis was at the only other occupied table when I was here.