But disappointed with my meal at this local stalwart. The skin on my Arctic char was limp and fatty and my partner's lobster roll was drowning in mayo. Service was good tho.
Lobster roll a little overrated. It is fine. But not a huge standout. Obviously people here have not tried a hot buttered lobster roll at Lenny and Joe's Fish Tale in Connecticut.
Great lobster roll and bouillabaisse, although serving sizes are inconsistent. However, service is horrendous. Also, pricey, even by West Village standards.
Disappointed. The artichokes side dish was like eating dried leaves. Fish of the day was grilled nicely but nothing special. Lobster knuckles was not outstanding, didn’t taste fresh.
I know you want a lobster roll, but that's the wrong move here. At Mary's you want to go for a whole fish. Ask your server which one, they'll know what's best today.